“If all the kids were jumping off a cliff would you join them?” This was the response from my either of my parents whenever I wanted to do something all the other kids were doing, a cynical answer to be sure. They wanted to be sure we kids weren’t just following the crowd trying to keep up with the latest fad, a lesson I think I learned pretty well, since I don’t consider myself particularly a follower of fads. In fact, at the University of Kentucky, one colleague thought he was being disparaging when he called me a contrarian. I thought a minute about his comment, then decided I kind of liked not going along with the crowd.
I think the disciple Thomas the twin could perhaps be called a contrarian too. He didn’t go along with the other disciples, who were telling wild stories about their rabbi, who had been crucified in front of the entire town of Jerusalem. He didn’t believe tales of a risen Christ, something nearly impossible to grasp. He didn’t swallow any of it, hadn’t been there, and couldn’t be convinced without seeing it himself. He wasn’t one to go along with the crowd, even if they were his close buddies with whom he had spent nearly three years’ traveling with, being close to this rabbi Jesus of Nazareth.
To top it off, this Jesus had been cruelly and shamefully executed on the orders of the Jewish chief priests, who were jealous of the great throng of followers Jesus had attracted, even as he talked against what hypocrites the temple authorities were. Thomas, perhaps expecting a different rabbi, an altogether more positive outcome from this man whom some called the messiah, could not believe the claims of rising from the dead, without seeing for himself. Thomas’s faith was one of hard facts, of sensate touching, seeing, hearing, for himself, just as he touched, saw and heard Jesus when he was alive. Thomas’s personality does not allow for unsubstantiated belief. Thomas doesn’t want a faith that he can’t support by truth, and to him, truth is bound up in experience.
Many of us have the same personalities that require experience. We don’t just follow the crowd, go for the latest fad, we want our life to be uniquely ours. In fact, this individualism characterizes much of American life. While we follow the fads, we also want to do it our way, in our own time, by the rules we find most fair and equal.
This individualism also spills over into our faith lives in America. People pick and choose what they want to do with their spirituality nowadays. They rarely pick a church because it is the denomination they grew up in, if they grew up in any faith tradition at all. They may find just as much to meet their needs outside of church or not in any faith walk at all, in a kind of proud claim to being “spiritual but not religious,” where they don’t ever enter a church building, except perhaps to attend a concert. They don’t read scripture, but may read self-help books claiming a kind of spirituality, and follow web sites of gurus giving spiritual platitudes.
The devolvement of our spiritual life into this amorphous walk sounds a lot like doubting Thomas. Experience takes over from blind faith. We know from the letter to the Hebrews that ”faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.” We are far from this kind of faith, as was Thomas the twin.
Is this to be applauded or lamented? Is blind faith without experience the best kind of faith?
I believe that each of us in our individual personality has needs for faith that meet our particular way of seeing the world. Some of us are skeptics like Thomas who believe only in those ideas that can be proved and experienced. We would be the ones in the locked room with the disciples, afraid that we were about to be persecuted for being followers of a man who was executed as a political criminal. Without our doubt, we could have no faith, could not enter into believing an incredulous thing. Thomas had this personality, and so did the apostle Paul, who actively persecuted the followers of Jesus of Nazareth, until he too had a face to face encounter with the risen Christ.
Then there are those among us who can take our minds and souls beyond our senses, to places that might exist, to ideas that resonate with us on a level beyond the world at our fingertips. These people believe that Christ rose from the dead, even when they don’t have evidence. They believe because they seek God everywhere perhaps, or perhaps they need the reassurance of God’s presence in a rabbi who rose from the dead. They believe in the miracle because they also believe in God’s abiding love for humanity, and God’s promise to make all things new.
Then there are those of us who fall somewhere in between these two types, who may believe, without evidence, some days but not others, depending on our mood, our needs and wants, or what’s happening in our life.
One thing I know for sure, is that, whatever your basic way of dealing with the world, whether you are one to follow the crowd, or one to doubt everything you hear, or one who needs evidence, or one whose belief system encompasses many things you can’t touch or see with your senses—God can reach you. God can make all things new with you, meeting you wherever you are in your faith journey, using your own basic world view to find you.
God doesn’t ask us to mold our way of thinking into one way to believe, only one path to faith. Just like God found Thomas in his doubts, God finds each of us in our unique faith. Trust God’s ways of meeting you on your path.